Today we will be talking about “Spring Boot @Valid vs @Validated”. When it comes to building web applications, it’s essential to handle input validation to ensure data integrity and security. In Spring Boot, two commonly used annotations for input validation are @Valid and @Validated. In this blog post, we’ll delve into the differences between these two annotations, their use cases, and when to choose one over the other.
Table of Contents
Understanding the Basics
Before diving into the comparison, let’s establish a fundamental understanding of what @Valid and @Validated do in a Spring Boot application.
@Valid
@Valid is a standard Java annotation, and it’s part of the Java Bean Validation framework (JSR 380). It is used to validate the properties of an object, typically within the context of a Spring MVC controller. This annotation triggers validation of the annotated object and its properties by the Bean Validation framework. If any validation constraints are violated, it will result in a MethodArgumentNotValidException being thrown, which can be handled by a global exception handler.
Here’s an example of how @Valid is used in a Spring Boot controller:
@RestController
@RequestMapping("/api/users")
public class UserController {
@PostMapping
public ResponseEntity<User> createUser(@RequestBody @Valid User user) {
// Business logic to create a user
return ResponseEntity.ok(user);
}
}In this example, the @Valid annotation is applied to the User object passed as a request body. The User object’s properties will be validated based on the constraints defined in the User class.
@Validated
@Validated is a Spring-specific annotation used for method-level validation. It is typically applied to controller methods and service methods to validate method parameters. Unlike @Valid, @Validated provides more fine-grained control over the validation process. It allows you to specify validation groups, enabling you to validate different groups of constraints at different points in your application.
Here’s an example of how @Validated is used:
@Service
@Validated
public class UserService {
@NotNull(groups = {CreateUser.class})
public User createUser(@Valid User user) {
// Business logic to create a user
return user;
}
}In this example, the @Validated annotation is applied to the UserService class, and the @NotNull constraint specifies that the createUser method should only be validated when the CreateUser validation group is targeted.
Now that we have a basic understanding of @Valid and @Validated, let’s explore the differences between the two.
Simple Guide To Dockerize Java Application Maven With Dockerfile [2020]
Key Differences
1. Scope of Application
The primary difference between @Valid and @Validated lies in their scope of application:
@Validis used to validate objects and their properties, typically within a Spring MVC controller method.@Validatedis used to validate method parameters, typically within service methods, and provides more fine-grained control over the validation process.
The choice between the two depends on where and how you want to perform validation in your application.
2. Validation Groups
Validation groups are a significant feature provided by @Validated. They allow you to group and validate constraints selectively based on specific use cases. This can be extremely useful in scenarios where you want to apply different sets of constraints in various situations.
For example, you might want to validate a user’s information differently when they are registering (requiring username, email, and password) compared to when they are updating their profile (where only email changes might be allowed).
With @Validated, you can define different validation groups and apply them as needed. This level of control is not available with @Valid.
3. Exception Handling
Another difference is in how exceptions are handled:
- When using
@Valid, the validation exceptions result in aMethodArgumentNotValidExceptionbeing thrown, which can be caught and handled globally or within the controller method. - With
@Validated, you have more control over how validation exceptions are handled. You can define custom validation groups and customize the exception handling for specific scenarios.
The choice between these two mechanisms depends on your project’s requirements. If you need finer-grained control over exception handling, @Validated is the way to go.
Use Cases
Now that we’ve explored the differences between @Valid and @Validated, let’s consider some common use cases for each annotation.
When to Use @Valid
- You’re working with Spring MVC controllers, and you want to validate the request body (usually a DTO) or form data.
- You don’t need fine-grained control over validation groups.
- You prefer the default exception handling provided by Spring Boot for validation errors.
Here’s an example use case for @Valid:
@RestController
@RequestMapping("/api/orders")
public class OrderController {
@PostMapping
public ResponseEntity<Order> createOrder(@RequestBody @Valid OrderDTO orderDTO) {
// Business logic to create an order
return ResponseEntity.ok(order);
}
}In this scenario, @Valid is an excellent choice for validating the orderDTO object.
When to Use @Validated
- You want to validate method parameters, either in service methods or controller methods.
- You need to apply different sets of validation constraints to different scenarios (using validation groups).
- You want fine-grained control over how validation exceptions are handled.
Here’s an example use case for @Validated:
@Service
@Validated
public class OrderService {
@NotNull(groups = {CreateOrder.class})
public Order createOrder(@Valid OrderDTO orderDTO) {
// Business logic to create an order
return order;
}
@NotNull(groups = {UpdateOrder.class})
public Order updateOrder(@Valid OrderDTO orderDTO) {
// Business logic to update an order
return order;
}
}In this scenario, @Validated is beneficial as it allows you to define different validation groups (CreateOrder and UpdateOrder) and apply them to the createOrder and updateOrder methods.
All About Java Regular Expressions Regex 2019
Spring Boot @Valid vs @Validated: Best Practices
To make the most of @Valid and @Validated, consider the following best practices:
1. Organize Your Validation Logic
Whether you choose @Valid or @Validated, it’s essential to keep your validation logic organized. Create separate validation classes or methods to encapsulate your constraints, and then apply them where needed. This keeps your codebase clean and makes it easier to manage and maintain your validation rules.
2. Use Validation Groups Wisely
If you opt for @Validated, use validation groups to their full potential. This allows you to apply different sets of constraints based on the specific scenario. However, avoid overcomplicating your code with an excessive number of validation groups. Keep it simple and maintainable.
3. Customize Exception Handling
If you require customized exception handling for validation errors, consider using @Validated. You can define custom exception handling for each validation group, providing a more tailored experience for handling different validation scenarios.
4. Document
Your Validation Constraints
Whichever annotation you choose, document your validation constraints clearly. Use comments or annotations to describe the purpose of each constraint, making it easier for developers to understand and maintain the validation rules.
5. Consider Cross-Field Validation
For more complex validation scenarios that involve cross-field validation (where the validity of one field depends on the value of another), you may need to use custom validation logic in addition to standard Bean Validation constraints. Both @Valid and @Validated can work with custom validators to achieve this.
Official Documentation
https://spring.io/guides/gs/validating-form-input/
Conclusion
In Spring Boot, both @Valid and @Validated are essential tools for input validation. The choice between them depends on your specific use case and requirements.
- Use
@Validwhen you need to validate objects and their properties within a Spring MVC controller method. It’s a straightforward way to handle input validation, and it’s particularly useful for request body or form data validation. - Use
@Validatedwhen you require fine-grained control over method parameter validation, want to apply different sets of constraints using validation groups, or need customized exception handling for specific validation scenarios.
Ultimately, the choice between @Valid and @Validated should align with your project’s architecture and validation needs. By understanding the differences and best practices for each, you can make informed decisions and build robust, well-validated Spring Boot applications.
